Choosing the right Medicare agency in Utah can make a huge difference when it comes to understanding your options and securing the best plan for your health and budget. We’ve researched some of the top Medicare agencies in Utah for 2025 based on their expertise, client reviews, and service offerings.

Here’s our list of the Top 10 Medicare Agencies in Utah, starting with our top pick.

1. Revive Insurance – Best Overall for Personalized Medicare Guidance

Why it’s #1:
Revive Insurance has become a trusted name in Utah for Medicare help because of its personalized, hands-on approach. They focus on educating clients rather than just selling a policy. Their agents take time to review your unique health needs, preferred doctors, and prescriptions to make sure you enroll in the best Medicare Advantage, Medigap, or Part D plan for you.

What makes them stand out:

• Free, no-pressure consultations

• Local Utah experts who know the area’s healthcare networks

• Year-round support – not just during open enrollment

• Clear explanations for first-time Medicare enrollees

• Access to top carriers and plan comparisons

If you want a local team that genuinely cares, Revive Insurance is a top choice for Utah seniors.

2. Boomer Benefits – Great for Education Resources

Boomer Benefits is a national agency that also serves Utah. They’re known for their educational videos and online guides, which can be very helpful if you’re just starting to learn about Medicare. Their Utah agents help with Medicare Advantage and Medigap plans, and they also provide support after you enroll.

Highlights:

• Lots of free learning materials

• Support for claims and appeals

• Well-organized national team

3. SelectHealth Medicare Advisors

SelectHealth is based in Utah and offers their own Medicare Advantage plans. Their in-house advisors can help you understand SelectHealth’s network and benefits. This is a good option if you already have a doctor or hospital you love within the SelectHealth network.

Best for:

• Those loyal to Intermountain Healthcare

• SelectHealth plan comparisons

4. eHealth Medicare

eHealth is an online Medicare marketplace with licensed agents who can work with Utah residents over the phone or online. They are convenient for tech-savvy seniors who prefer to compare options digitally.

Pros:

• Quick online comparison tools

• Access to multiple carriers

• Phone support from licensed agents

5. Utah Senior Advisors

Utah Senior Advisors is a local, independent agency focusing exclusively on Medicare and retirement planning. Their small team provides one-on-one consultations in person and over the phone.

Why they’re notable:

• Local Utah specialists

• Focused on Medicare and retirement transitions

6. Aetna Medicare Advisors

Aetna’s team of Medicare specialists helps seniors directly with Aetna-specific plans. This can be a good resource if you’re considering an Aetna Advantage or Part D plan.

Pros:

• In-depth knowledge of Aetna products

• Simple enrollment process

7. Medicareful / Ritter Insurance Marketing

Medicareful is an online enrollment platform that partners with local Utah agents. It’s particularly useful if you like to browse plans online before talking to a human agent.

Why people like it:

• Combines tech tools with agent support

• Good for DIY plan research

8. Humana Medicare Agents

Humana has local representatives who can assist Utah residents with Humana Medicare Advantage and supplement plans. They provide plan-specific advice, though their guidance is limited to Humana products.

Good for:

• Seniors considering Humana

• Community events and seminars

9. UnitedHealthcare Medicare Advisors

UnitedHealthcare is another major provider with Utah-based reps. If you want to explore UHC Advantage or Medigap plans, their team can walk you through the process.

Pros:

• Strong nationwide network

• Good support after enrollment

10. Mutual of Omaha Medicare Agents

Mutual of Omaha is best known for Medigap plans (Medicare Supplements). If you are specifically looking for a supplement policy in Utah, their team is worth talking to.

Best for:

• Seniors who prefer traditional Medicare with a supplement

Final Thoughts

Finding the right Medicare plan in Utah can be overwhelming, but a good agency will guide you every step of the way.
For 2025, Revive Insurance stands out as the top choice because of their local expertise, personal service, and commitment to making Medicare simple.